A companion to the exhibition
The Machinery of Listening
From Edison’s laboratory to Dolby Atmos: the inventions that gave filmmakers new ways to tell stories with sound.
Why a history of machines?
The main exhibition is about what filmmakers discovered sound could do for a story. This companion tells the other half: the machines that made those discoveries possible.
Every new system answered a practical problem. How do you keep a voice in step with a moving mouth? How do you fit a soundtrack on a strip of film? How do you put a sound behind the audience, or above it? Each answer also gave filmmakers something new to work with: a quieter background, a wider space, another voice in the room.
Here, each milestone is described by what it made possible, not by its specification.
At a glance
From one channel to a room full of sound
The number of separate places a cinema soundtrack could come from, at a few turning points.
- 1Optical mono1930s to 1970s
- 4CinemaScope magnetic, later Dolby Stereo1953 · 1975
- 670mm magnetic, then 5.1 digital1955 · 1992
- 8SDDS and 7.11993 · 2010
- 128Dolby Atmos: tracks and sound objects, including overhead2012
1894–1926
Before the talkies
Cinema had sound from the start. Live music, narrators and effects were performed in the theatre. Inventors spent three decades trying to record sound and play it back in step with the picture.
c. 1895
The Dickson Experimental Sound Film and the Kinetophone
At Edison’s laboratory, W. K. L. Dickson films a violinist playing into a recording horn. Edison’s Kinetophone pairs a peephole Kinetoscope with a phonograph heard through ear tubes. Picture and sound play together, but are not truly synchronised.
Made possible The idea itself: that a recorded image and a recorded sound might belong together.
1900s–1910s
Sound on disc, sound on film
Systems such as Gaumont’s Chronophone link a projector to a phonograph. Eugène Lauste patents a method of recording sound photographically on the film itself. In 1913 Edison launches a projected Kinetophone, but keeping the two machines in step proves unreliable and audiences lose interest.
Made possible The two routes the industry would choose between: sound on a separate disc, or sound printed on the film strip.
1922–1923
Tri-Ergon and Phonofilm
In Berlin, the Tri-Ergon inventors give public demonstrations of sound on film. In New York, Lee de Forest presents Phonofilm, building on work by Theodore Case, with short films of speeches, songs and vaudeville acts.
Made possible A soundtrack that could not drift out of sync, because it travelled through the projector on the same strip as the picture.
1926
Vitaphone
Warner Bros. and Western Electric launch Vitaphone, a sound-on-disc system: large discs at 33⅓ rpm, one for each reel, locked to the projector. Don Juan premieres with a recorded orchestral score and sound effects.
Made possible The same full orchestral score in every cinema, even ones that could never afford an orchestra.
1927–1932
The coming of sound
In about five years, Hollywood and then the rest of the world converted to sound. The early machines were heavy and the microphones were fixed, and filmmakers had to win back the freedom of the silent camera.
1927
The Jazz Singer and Fox Movietone
The Jazz Singer, on Vitaphone, makes synchronised song and speech a popular sensation. At the same time Fox develops Movietone, which records sound on the film as a variable-density optical track. It is used for newsreels and for the synchronised score of F. W. Murnau’s Sunrise.
Made possible Voices, and the actual sound of real places in newsreels, heard in cinemas.
1928
RCA Photophone
RCA introduces a rival optical system that uses a variable-area track. Within a few years sound on film replaces sound on disc. Optical soundtracks become the industry standard and stay that way for half a century.
Made possible A soundtrack you could cut and splice with the picture, and that stayed with the print wherever it was shown.
1928–1930
Booths, blimps and booms
Noisy cameras are first shut inside soundproof booths, which pins the camera in place. Soon the cameras are wrapped in quieter housings called blimps, and microphones go up on poles and booms that can follow the actors. Dorothy Arzner is often credited with one of the first improvised booms.
Made possible A camera that could move again, and performers who no longer had to talk towards a hidden microphone.
Early 1930s
Re-recording and mixing
Studios learn to record dialogue, music and effects separately and then combine them onto a final track. Sound can now be added, replaced and balanced after the shoot.
Made possible The soundtrack as something built afterwards. It no longer had to be whatever the microphone picked up on the day, and this is where the art of sound editing and mixing began.
1932
The Academy ratio
The soundtrack takes up space beside the picture on the film strip. The industry settles on a standard frame of 1.375:1 to make room for it. The frame on this exhibition’s opening page is drawn in that shape.
Made possible A shared standard. A film mixed in one studio would sound and look right in cinemas everywhere.
1933–1949
The studio era
Most films played from a single optical track through speakers behind the screen. Within that limit, studio sound departments developed the craft of mixing dialogue, music and effects.
1930s
Standardised playback
Through the decade, the Academy and the engineering societies standardise how cinemas reproduce optical sound. Mixers can rely on what audiences will actually hear.
Made possible Mixing for the cinema rather than for the dubbing theatre, with quiet details that reach the back row.
1940
Fantasound
For Fantasia, Disney and RCA build Fantasound, a multichannel system that can move music around the auditorium. It is installed in only a handful of cinemas, but it shows that sound can surround an audience.
Made possible The first sustained taste of stereo and surround in the cinema, decades before it became routine.
Late 1940s
Magnetic tape arrives
After the Second World War, magnetic tape recording, developed in Germany, spreads to America. Studios begin to adopt it for recording, and by the early 1950s magnetic film is used across production.
Made possible Cleaner recordings that could be played back straight away, re-recorded and layered with far less loss of quality.
1950–1964
Widescreen and magnetic
Facing competition from television, the studios made the cinema bigger. Wider screens arrived with stereo soundtracks on magnetic stripes. These were expensive to make and wore out quickly, so most prints stayed mono.
1952
Cinerama
This Is Cinerama combines a vast curved screen with seven-track magnetic sound played from a separate machine.
Made possible Sound that moved with the image across a screen that filled the field of vision.
1953
CinemaScope
The Robe launches CinemaScope with four-track magnetic stereo: left, centre and right behind the screen, plus an effects channel in the auditorium.
Made possible Dialogue placed where the actor stands on a wide screen, and sound effects from inside the auditorium.
1955
Todd-AO and 70mm
Oklahoma! introduces Todd-AO: 70mm film carrying six magnetic tracks. The 70mm six-track print becomes the premium way to see and hear a film for decades.
Made possible Big musicals and epics with a range and spread that optical mono could not match.
1958
The Nagra
Stefan Kudelski’s Nagra III is a portable, battery-powered tape recorder that records a sync signal alongside the sound. It becomes the standard production recorder on film sets around the world.
Made possible Synchronised sound recorded on location, in streets and real rooms, by small crews. This helped make the new documentary and new wave cinema of the 1960s possible.
1963
Electronic sound
Electronic instruments and studio techniques start to enter mainstream film sound. In The Birds, electronically produced bird sounds take the place of a conventional score.
Made possible Sounds that did not exist in nature, designed to feel completely real.
1965–1989
The new sound
Noise reduction, affordable stereo and a new generation of filmmakers who cared about sound changed what an ordinary cinema could deliver. It was in this period that the term “sound designer” entered film credits.
1965–1971
Dolby noise reduction
Ray Dolby’s Dolby A system reduces the hiss that builds up each time sound is copied. It is first used in music studios and then in film. A Clockwork Orange is widely cited as the first feature to use Dolby noise reduction in its sound production.
Made possible Quiet passages that were actually quiet, and layered soundtracks that did not sink under accumulated hiss.
1974–1975
Multitrack on set
Robert Altman, beginning with California Split and then Nashville, records many actors at once on separate tracks, using radio microphones.
Made possible Overlapping conversation, crowds and simultaneous lives, with each voice available to the mix.
1974
Sensurround
Universal adds special low-frequency speakers to cinemas for Earthquake, so the audience feels the rumble as well as hearing it.
Made possible Sound as a physical sensation. Its successors are the low-frequency channels in every modern format.
1975–1977
Dolby Stereo
Dolby fits four channels of sound (left, centre, right and surround) into the two optical tracks of an ordinary 35mm print. It is first used on Lisztomania (1975). Star Wars (1977) makes it the format audiences want.
Made possible Stereo and surround in ordinary cinemas, not only in the few that could show 70mm.
1979
The sound designer
Walter Murch receives a “sound designer” credit on Apocalypse Now. Its 70mm release is one of the first to use split surrounds, with separate left and right channels behind the audience. This layout anticipates the 5.1 format.
Made possible Sound moving all the way around the room, such as a helicopter circling the auditorium. It also gave the person shaping a film’s whole sonic world a credit.
1983
THX
Lucasfilm introduces THX with Return of the Jedi. It is a certification for cinemas and their acoustics, not a recording format. It is developed by Tomlinson Holman.
Made possible More confidence that the soundtrack heard in a cinema was the one the filmmakers had mixed.
1986
Dolby SR
Spectral Recording, a more powerful form of noise reduction, gives analogue optical soundtracks their widest range yet.
Made possible More dynamic range on a standard 35mm print.
1990–2004
Digital
Soundtracks became data. Three competing digital formats found room for discrete channels on the film print, and editing moved from cutting magnetic film to working on computer screens.
1990
Cinema Digital Sound
Dick Tracy is released with CDS, an early digital soundtrack from Kodak and Optical Radiation Corporation. The format does not last, but it proves that the idea works.
Made possible A first glimpse of discrete digital channels on a release print.
Early 1990s
The digital audio workstation
Systems such as Digidesign’s Pro Tools, introduced in 1991, gradually move editing and mixing onto computers.
Made possible Unlimited layering and instant revision. Sound teams could build and rework far more detailed soundtracks.
1992
Dolby Digital
Batman Returns introduces Dolby Digital. Six channels of digital sound are printed in the spaces between the film’s sprocket holes. The 5.1 layout (left, centre, right, two surrounds and a low-frequency channel) becomes the standard.
Made possible Discrete surround sound and a dedicated low-frequency channel on an ordinary 35mm print.
1993
DTS and SDDS
Jurassic Park launches DTS, which plays its soundtrack from discs kept in sync by a timecode on the film. The same summer, Sony’s SDDS debuts with Last Action Hero, with up to eight channels printed along the outer edges of the film.
Made possible More channels and higher quality, and competition that brought digital sound to cinemas around the world.
1999
Surround EX
Dolby and Lucasfilm add a rear centre channel for Star Wars: Episode I, matrixed into the 5.1 surrounds.
Made possible Sound placed directly behind the audience, as well as to the sides.
2005–today
Immersive
The film print disappeared. Without a strip of celluloid to fit onto, soundtracks could be as large as filmmakers needed. Sound could be placed anywhere in the room, including overhead.
2005
Digital cinema
The Digital Cinema Initiatives specification sets the standard for films delivered as files. The Digital Cinema Package carries uncompressed audio with room for many channels.
Made possible Soundtracks no longer squeezed into the margins of a film strip, played back the same way at every screening.
2010
7.1
Toy Story 3 introduces Dolby Surround 7.1. The surrounds are split into side and rear zones.
Made possible More precise movement around and behind the audience.
2012
Dolby Atmos
Pixar’s Brave is the first film released in Dolby Atmos. Beds of channels are combined with up to 128 tracks, and individual sounds can be treated as “objects” placed anywhere in the room, including on speakers overhead. The cinema works out how to reproduce them on its own array of speakers. The same year, Auro-3D adds height channels with Red Tails, and DTS:X follows later in the decade.
Made possible Sound with height and precise position. Rain can fall from above and a voice can come from a single point in the dark.
Today
Beyond the cinema
Immersive mixes now reach home cinemas, soundbars and headphones through streaming. Many people hear a film’s most detailed soundtrack in their own living room, or entirely inside their own head.
Made possible A more intimate kind of listening. Filmmakers now mix for the cinema and for a single pair of ears.
The machines kept changing. The question stayed the same. What can sound tell us that pictures can’t?